The creative strategist is the person who decides which ads to produce, and why. They start from data (campaign results, customer reviews, competitors' ads), draw angles and hooks from it, write the briefs, organise the tests and read the results to decide on the next batch. They are the link between the media buyer, who manages budgets, and production, which shoots and edits. The role has taken hold because the platforms have automated targeting: on TikTok as on Meta, what remains in the advertiser's hands is mainly the creative. TikTok, for instance, recommends 3 to 5 different creatives per ad group, and "very different" creatives for testing (TikTok Ads help centre). You still need to know which ones. That is the job of creative strategy, which we break down here from a brand's point of view.
What Does a Creative Strategist Do Day to Day?
They turn scattered information into a production plan: which messages to test, in what form, in what order, and how to tell which ones earn their place. Their work breaks down into six activities:
| Activity | What they do | Deliverable |
|---|---|---|
| Customer research | Reading reviews, comments, customer service questions and interview transcripts | A list of motivations, objections and the words customers use |
| Competitor monitoring | Analysing the active ads of competitors and neighbouring brands | A map of the angles already used and those still available |
| Angles and hooks | Turning each motivation into a message, and each message into video openings | An angles × hooks × formats matrix |
| Briefs | Writing what production needs to shoot: hook, structure, proof, call to action | One brief per video or per batch |
| Test plan | Deciding what to test at the same time, with what budget and what stopping criterion | A testing calendar |
| Analysis and iteration | Reading results by creative, understanding why a video wins, deciding on variants | A report and the next batch |
For competitor monitoring, the basic tool is public: the Meta Ad Library contains all active ads running across Meta technologies. On TikTok, the Ad Library and the Creative Center play the same role; we explain how to use them in our article on the TikTok Ads Library and the Creative Center.
Why Has Creative Strategy Become So Important?
Because creative remains the main driver of advertising effectiveness, and campaign automation has taken most of the other levers away from advertisers.
The underlying finding is not new. In an analysis published in October 2017, Nielsen notes that in 2006 Project Apollo attributed 65% of advertising's effect on sales to the creative. The NCSolutions study it presents, covering nearly 500 consumer packaged goods campaigns run in 2016 and the first quarter of 2017, shows that the share attributable to media rose from 15% to 36% in eleven years, but that creative remains "the undisputed champion" of sales drivers. It also observes that weak creative produces a weak sales effect, and that whatever effect remains then comes mainly from media.
What has changed since is the way media is bought. Meta's and TikTok's automated campaigns decide for themselves who to show which ad to. Advertisers no longer fine-tune their audiences; they supply creatives and the machine sorts them. If all the creatives look alike, the machine has nothing to sort. Hence TikTok's guidance in its creative best practices, updated in June 2025: 3 to 5 creatives per ad group, 3 to 5 diversified ad groups per campaign, very different creatives for testing, and refreshing creatives when performance declines steadily.
Producing that volume at random is expensive. The creative strategist's job is to make sure every video produced tests a different hypothesis.
Creative Strategist, Creative Director, Media Buyer: Who Does What?
The creative strategist decides what to say and what to test; the creative director decides how to say it; the media buyer decides where to run it and with what budget. The boundaries vary from team to team, but the most common split is as follows:
| Role | Question they answer | KPIs they watch |
|---|---|---|
| Creative strategist | Which messages and hooks should we test, and what have we learnt? | Hook rate, retention, CTR, cost per result by creative |
| Creative director | How do we make this message memorable and consistent with the brand? | Quality of execution, brand consistency |
| Media buyer | Where should we run ads, with what budget, and what campaign structure? | CPM, overall cost per result, ROAS, volume |
| Social media manager | What should we post organically, and how do we engage the community? | Reach, engagement, followers |
| UGC creator or actor | How do we deliver the script convincingly? | Delivery that matches the brief |
In a small team, one person often combines two of these roles. The most common combination, and the riskiest, is media buyer and creative strategist: the person managing the budget rarely has time to read 300 customer reviews.
How Does a Creative Strategist Build Ad Tests?
With a matrix: a few angles, several hooks per angle, and one variable tested at a time. An angle is a reason to buy (saving time, avoiding a mistake, giving a gift). A hook is the way the video opens on that angle. The format is the shape: talking-head testimonial, demonstration, comparison, "3 reasons to".
| Angle | Hook A | Hook B | Format |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saving time | Question: "How long does it take you to…?" | Figure: "12 minutes instead of an hour" | Demonstration |
| Avoiding a mistake | Mistake: "The mistake everyone makes with…" | Before / after | Talking-head testimonial |
| Social proof | Customer review read aloud | Reaction of a creator discovering the product | UGC |
The rules they set so that the test actually means something:
- One hypothesis per video. If the hook, angle and format all change at once, you cannot tell what made the difference.
- Clear-cut differences. TikTok recommends this explicitly: it is better to test very different creatives than variants that differ by a word or two.
- Hook first. TikTok advises crafting the hook within the first 6 seconds and presenting the value proposition within the first 3 (source). That is where most of the gap between two videos is decided.
- A stopping criterion written in advance. A minimum budget or impression volume before judging, and a cost per result above which you cut.
- A report after each batch. What won, what lost and, above all, the hypothesis that explains why.
Which KPIs Does a Creative Strategist Track?
The KPIs that isolate the effect of the creative, from first contact through to conversion. Each one corresponds to a part of the video:
| Point in the video | KPI | What it says about the creative |
|---|---|---|
| The first few seconds | Hook rate: 3-second views (Meta) or 2-second views (TikTok) divided by impressions | Does the hook stop the scroll? |
| The middle | 6-second views on TikTok, average watch time, completion rate | Does the structure deliver on the hook's promise? |
| The end | Click-through rate (CTR) | Does the call to action make people want to go further? |
| After the click | Cost per purchase, per lead or per install | Is the video attracting the right people? |
| Over time | Change in cost per result from one week to the next | Is the creative wearing out? |
The last KPI is the one that triggers the next round of production. TikTok recommends refreshing an ad group's creatives when results show a steady decline, and adding the new creatives to the existing ad group rather than creating a new one. The creative strategist plans ahead: the next batch must be ready before the previous one runs out of steam.
What Are a Creative Strategist's Deliverables?
The core deliverable is the brief: a short document that lets production shoot without coming back with questions. A good video ad brief contains:
- The objective and the KPI that will show whether the video has succeeded.
- The audience, described by their situation and their problem, not just their age.
- The angle, in one sentence.
- Two or three hooks, written word for word, with what appears on screen.
- The structure: problem, demonstration or proof, call to action.
- The permitted proof (figures, reviews, labels) and the prohibited claims.
- Format constraints: length, 9:16, safe zones, subtitles.
- Mandatory disclosures, including the "Publicité" or "Collaboration commerciale" label required by the law of 9 June 2023 when a paid creator promotes the product.
On top of this come the test matrix, the production calendar and, after each batch, the learnings report. That last document is often the most valuable: after six months, it becomes the memory of what makes your customers buy.
Hire a Creative Strategist or Use an Agency?
Hiring makes sense when you already produce a lot of videos and your media budget is stable; using an agency makes sense when you need both strategy and production. An in-house creative strategist without production capacity writes briefs that nobody shoots quickly enough.
| Criterion | In-house creative strategist | Agency with a creative strategist |
|---|---|---|
| Product knowledge | Deep, day to day | Built at the outset, through customer research |
| Production volume | Depends on your shooting resources | Included: casting, shoot, editing |
| Outside perspective | Fades over time | Fed by other sectors and other accounts |
| Cost | A salary, plus production | A flat fee covering strategy and production |
| Main risk | A bottleneck on a single person | An agency that delivers videos without a test plan |
To assess a creative strategist, in-house or at an agency, ask three questions: what hypothesis was each of the latest videos testing? What did you learn from the last batch? What is the next batch, and why that one? Precise answers are worth more than a beautiful portfolio.
How Does Esekai Organise Creative Strategy?
Every Esekai client has a dedicated creative strategist upstream, and a single project manager from brief to delivery. It is set out in our method. The creative strategist carries out the research, builds the matrix of angles and hooks and writes the briefs; our team shoots and edits in-house, with two hooks per video so that every shoot serves a test. Performance results go back to the creative strategist, who decides on the next batch.
This is how our creative ads studio works, for TikTok as well as Meta. It comes with a written commitment on the same page: if your CPA does not fall by 20% within 90 days, we keep working at no extra cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a creative strategist?
- The person who decides which ads to produce and why. They analyse performance data, customer reviews and competitors' ads, draw angles and hooks from them, write the briefs, organise the tests and read the results to decide on the next batch.
- What Is Creative Strategy?
- The method that links research (customers, competitors, campaign data) to ad production. It answers three questions: which messages to test, in what format, and how to tell which ones work.
- Creative Strategist vs Creative Director: What's the Difference?
- The creative strategist decides what to say and what to test, based on data. The creative director decides how to say it so that it is memorable and consistent with the brand. The two roles complement each other.
- How Many Creatives Should You Test?
- TikTok recommends 3 to 5 different creatives per ad group and 3 to 5 diversified ad groups per campaign, with very different creatives when testing. The creative strategist decides what each one should test.
- Which Metrics Does a Creative Strategist Track?
- The hook rate (3-second views on Meta, 2-second views on TikTok, divided by impressions), retention, click-through rate and cost per result of each creative, as well as how they change over time to spot creative fatigue.
- Does Esekai Provide a Creative Strategist?
- Yes. Every client has a dedicated creative strategist upstream and a single project manager from brief to delivery, as set out in the Esekai method.
A Dedicated Creative Strategist, and the Team to Shoot Their Ideas
You now know what a creative strategist does and how to judge their work. At Esekai, every client has one, and our Paris studio shoots and edits in-house whatever they come up with: TikTok and Meta creative ads, UGC, two hooks per video, tests that make sense. Thirty minutes on the phone to see what that could look like for your brand.
Book a call →30 minutes to talk formats, budget and action plan.